Please wait...
we’re processing your request.

Published on 01/21/2025

Navigating Nightlife Security: Unraveling the Armed vs. Unarmed Guards Dilemma

Navigating Nightlife Security: Unraveling the Armed vs. Unarmed Guards Dilemma

Introduction

Explore the Rising Concern of Club and Bar Violence: A Companion to Our Nightclub Security Podcast

Stay informed and enhance your understanding of nightclub security with our dedicated "Nightclub Security" podcasts and blogs. Don't miss out!, listen to the accompanying podcast on this topic here or find it on iTunes by searching for "Nightclub Security."

The issue of club and bar violence is rapidly gaining prominence, and statistical data attests to the alarming increase on a national scale. As the number of violent incidents rises, owners and managers are faced with crucial decisions on the choice of security personnel.

At NSC, we take pride in being the nation's leading experts in training hospitality security professionals (aka bouncers), providing valuable insights to help operators minimize liquor liability, lower insurance premiums, and ultimately keep patrons and employees safe. Our commitment extends to empowering operators with the knowledge needed to make well-informed decisions. Read on and stay ahead in the decision-making process when it comes to preventing violence in your bar or nightclub. 

Let’s do a virtual role play. Below is an example of a likely incident involving a disgruntled patron who brandishes a firearm during the night. Let’s examine the incident and then imagine the three likely responses by both an unarmed and armed guard.

 

The Incident: A Tale of Nightclub Turbulence 

Three patrons, after a few drinks, engage in a verbal altercation with another group. Guards swiftly intervene, managing to separate the groups temporarily. The manager successfully calms the situation, allowing the patrons to remain inside. However, within 30 minutes, the argument reignites, prompting guards to usher the patrons towards the exit. The situation escalates into violence at the front door, with guards eventually subduing the group. As the patrons leave the venue, tensions persist, leading to a startling twist: one of them retrieves a handgun from under the passenger seat…

 

Exploring Possible Endings: Unveiling the Implications

Unarmed Response One: 

Amidst the chaos, the assailant opens fire at the front of the club, prompting both security guards and patrons to seek cover. Swiftly escaping in a vehicle, the shooter evades the scene, leaving a trail of panic behind. A quick-thinking individual dials 911 as the shots echo through the air.

Remarkably, the club bears the scars of the attack with 10 bullet holes, yet a stroke of fortune prevails—none of the shots find their mark on any individuals; everyone emerges unharmed. Subsequently, law enforcement successfully apprehends the suspects, leading to the prosecution of the perpetrator.

Now let’s discuss the possible responses – both for the unarmed and armed guard and see where this takes us. 

Unarmed Response Two: 

In a harrowing incident, a guest opens fire at the front of the club, prompting guards and patrons to scramble for cover. The shooter quickly flees the scene in a vehicle, leaving chaos in their wake. A prompt 911 call is made as gunfire echoes in the air.

The aftermath reveals a grim scene: the club bears 8 bullet holes, and unfortunately, 2 guards sustain gunshot wounds to their legs and back. Additionally, 3 guests suffer injuries to their arms, chest, leg, and back. Miraculously, none of the wounds prove fatal. Immediate response from law enforcement and medics ensures timely treatment for the victims.

In a significant turn of events, authorities successfully apprehend the suspects, leading to the prosecution of the shooter. This incident underscores the importance of effective security measures and emergency response in nightlife establishments.

Armed Response One: 

While the guests made their way to their car, a pair of armed guards discreetly accompanied the group, ensuring their safety in a non-confrontational manner. Suddenly, a tense situation unfolds as one of the guests brandishes a weapon and turns. In a swift response, both guards draw their weapons, shouting urgently for the individual to drop theirs.

Undeterred, the guest leaps into the waiting car, which speeds away. Startlingly, the individual points their gun out the window and discharges multiple rounds into the air. A quick-thinking bystander dials 911, and authorities swiftly apprehend the suspects a short distance away.

Upon investigation, law enforcement recovers a weapon, leading to the arrest of the shooter. This incident emphasizes the critical role of vigilant security measures in maintaining safety at public venues.

Armed Response Two: 

While the guests made their way to their car, a pair of armed guards discreetly accompanied the group, ensuring their safety in a non-confrontational manner. Suddenly, a tense situation unfolds as one of the guests brandishes a weapon and turns. In a swift response, both guards draw their weapons, shouting urgently for the individual to drop theirs.

Undeterred, the guest leaps into the waiting car, which speeds away. Startlingly, the individual points their gun out the window and discharges multiple rounds into the air. A quick-thinking bystander dials 911, and authorities swiftly apprehend the suspects a short distance away.

Upon investigation, law enforcement recovers a weapon, leading to the arrest of the shooter. This incident emphasizes the critical role of vigilant security measures in maintaining safety at public venues.

Armed Response Three: 

While the guests made their way to their car, a pair of armed guards discreetly trailed the group at a distance of approximately 20 to 25 feet. Tension escalates as one guest retrieves a weapon from the car and turns, spotting the armed guards drawing their weapons in response. Seizing the moment, the guest hastily jumps into the passenger seat, and the car accelerates.

In a startling turn of events, the guest extends the gun out of the passenger window, firing three rounds at the front of the club. The armed guards react by opening fire on the fleeing vehicle, inadvertently hitting not only the targeted car but also several uninvolved guest vehicles and a passing car. The chaotic scene prompts a prompt 911 call as gunshots echo through the air.

Law enforcement swiftly responds to the incident, capturing the suspects a short distance away. Upon investigation, authorities recover a weapon, leading to the arrest of the shooter. This incident underscores the importance of careful security measures and the potential consequences of high-risk situations in public spaces.

 

Decisions and Dilemmas: Posing Critical Questions for Operators

As operators grapple with the armed vs. unarmed guards dilemma, they must confront pivotal questions:

  • What is the primary goal? Is it to ensure venue and property safety, keep a perceived "bad element" at bay, or merely provide a show of force?
  • What is the underlying problem? Assessing the clientele, the role of promoters, club policies, and management presence is crucial to addressing the root causes of violence.
  • Is armed security necessary? Operators must evaluate whether better-trained guards, improved management, or enhanced policies could achieve the desired security.
  • Risk vs. Reward: Operators must weigh the potential downsides, including the risk of a shooting, police issues, negative guest and community perceptions, extra expenses, and insurance coverage for armed guards.

 

Conclusion:

In navigating this complex landscape, operators should engage in open dialogue with local authorities and staff. For further discussion on these questions or potential solutions, feel free to contact us directly.

Share this article


0 items | $0.00

X

Get Help